SMB3 vs. SMW

[slushie]

I always wonder this, and wonder what members think of this.
Which of these classic 2D Sidescrolling Mario titles is your favourite and why?

Both are my favourites, amazing games. But I always have to go with SMB3. It's just so perfect for a game.

Having separate worlds, each with their own look, feel, music, levels, is just so fun and cool. Having all the different suits and items which you can actually store for later, is also just amazing.
The music, is one of the best, every world's music, the ending music, the level music, just great.
And the graphics, the look, is just so great. Especially on the NES, really shows some nice looks. And its ports, also have a very nice, updated, classic feel to them.

SMW is great, but it just doesn't have the same sparkle for me SMB3 has.

[Chris]

I'd barely go with SMB3. The difficulty is better, and there are more powerups.

[Grooms]

SMB3 is more difficult, which I like, but I enjoy SMW more. I love being able to use Yoshi and the Star Road/secret levels are very fun.

[mignelli]

I defenitely like SMW soundtrack better, but SMB 3 is just bettter overall

[NintendoNerds]

I'm going with Super Mario World. Although SMB3 was evolutionary for the series, SMW was on the SNES and was personally a better designed game. I like the soundtrack more as well as the game play and game features.

Great poll Slushie

[slushie]

grooms said:

I love being able to use Yoshi and the Star Road/secret levels are very fun.

Yeah, SMW does have Yoshi, which does give it some extra points. Same with Star Road. I wonder how it would have been too see Yoshi in SMB3. Just have some levels have a block where you get an egg, or have an egg as an item to use before levels. Would have made SMB3 the ultimate game.

Something I just made quickly.

[NintendoNerds]

wow, great job slushie! I like it. It took me a second to realize what it was but it's actually pretty cool. Having Yoshi would have been such a great addition to SMB3 huh?

[Grimm Penguin]

SMB3 it looked great and i thought better then SMW